Go Home Toys
Khols Cares has the best puppy snuggle buddies. We love the price ($5), do not have plastic eyes and are squeaker free! Also they are a great size and quality.
The toy designs rotate so keep an eye out for a cute design! Just search Khols Cares on the Khols website.
We also recommend providing a yack cheese chew. We call them the "puppy pacifiers". They are a great for quiet time in the crate! There are several different brands and they can be purchased on Chewy or Amazon. You can get the large or jumbo chews and cut them in half for puppies.